NavMDs
Dr. Paul Carniol, MD - Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon in Summit, New Jersey

Dr. Paul Carniol, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

Otolaryngology
Summit, New Jersey
NPI: 1578591954· License: 25MA04250100 (NJ) verify
Medical school: Perelman School Of Med At The University Of Pennsylvania · Graduated 1976(~50 yrs since med school)
Industry payments (2025): $675 across 22 payments (what this means)
4.97(60 ratings)

Consultation $110

In Dr. Paul Carniol's own words

How Dr. Paul Carniol describes their own approach, from their Instagram posts. Each statement links to the original.

Specialization

  • Dr. Carniol specializes in facial plastic surgery, including rhinoplasty, Otoplasty, blepharoplasty, facelift & neck lift, and hair transplantation

Consultation

  • Book a consultation with Dr. Carniol to explore the treatment options that are right for you!

Statements are quoted or closely paraphrased from Dr. Paul Carniol's own public posts and are their claims, not NavMDs' medical advice. Doctors can correct or remove any item via their claimed profile or support [at] navmds.com.

About

Dr. Paul Carniol is a Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon practicing in Summit, New Jersey. He specializes in facial plastic and reconstructive surgery, offering procedures such as rhinoplasty, otoplasty, blepharoplasty, facelift, neck lift, and hair restoration. Dr. Carniol's philosophy emphasizes that the best enhancement is defined by how the patient feels, prioritizing comfort. He is recognized as a Castle Connolly Top Doctor for 2026, and his facility is a Top Facility for 2026 in Summit, NJ. He provides both in-office treatments and operating room procedures, often using local anesthesia to ensure patients are at ease and pain-free without deeper sedation. This approach allows many procedures to be performed in the office. Dr. Carniol focuses on creating rhinoplasty results that are functional and aesthetically pleasing, aiming for a balanced appearance that still looks like the patient. For newborn ear deformities, he utilizes non-invasive ear molding devices like EarWell, EarBuddies, and InfantEar Systems, emphasizing early intervention to gently reshape the ear and ideally avoid surgery later. Laser resurfacing is also offered for deeper concerns including fine lines, wrinkles, acne scars, and sun damage.

Connect with Dr. Paul Carniol on Social Media

Specialties

  • Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

Procedures & Services

Select a service to schedule an appointment · each is approximately 60 minutes

Average Cost of Surgery

Healthcare costs shouldn't be a mystery. Each figure below is the average of the total costs patients reported in their own published reviews of Dr. Paul Carniol, with the number of reports and the years they were written. Prices are not adjusted for inflation and are not a quote: your final cost is set at consultation and depends on your specific medical needs. How we calculate these prices

Botox

$850

Average of 2 patient reports · 2016

About typicalTypical in Summit: $400–$900 (median $550, 41 reports) compare ↗

Dermal Fillers

$1,800

1 patient report · 2016

About typicalTypical nationally: $700–$2,500 (median $1,301, 75 reports) compare ↗

Lipoma Removal

$5,000

1 patient report · 2017

Above typicalTypical nationally: $683–$3,500 (median $800, 7 reports) compare ↗

Help us keep this data current and accurate. If you've had a procedure with Dr. Paul Carniol, please take a moment to contribute your cost information.

Questions, Answers, and Information Directly from Dr. Paul Carniol

Sourced directly from Dr. Paul Carniol's social posts and replies.

What are the benefits of Otoplasty at Carniol Plastic Surgery?
Otoplasty is considered one of the most confidence-boosting procedures, with the self-assurance patients gain being the best possible result. It can achieve major confidence for patients in a single visit.
What is Dr. Carniol's philosophy and approach to Rhinoplasty?
Dr. Carniol focuses on achieving rhinoplasty results that are both functional and aesthetically pleasing. He addresses patients seeking a range of changes, from subtle refinement to more transformative alterations, with the goal of creating a more balanced appearance that still looks like the patient. A customized approach is utilized, aiming for a nose that perfectly fits the individual, which can lead to increased confidence lasting a lifetime.
What is Dr. Carniol's approach to non-surgical ear molding for newborns?
Dr. Carniol has extensive experience with non-invasive ear molding, utilizing devices like EarWell, EarBuddies, and InfantEar Systems, each with unique strengths. He carefully examines each baby's specific ear deformity to determine the most effective device and treatment plan. Early intervention is crucial for newborn ear deformities because a baby’s ear cartilage is soft and pliable for only a short time. The goal is to gently and painlessly reshape the ear, aiming for a natural, long-lasting result and ideally avoiding the need for surgical correction (otoplasty) later in childhood.
What are the limitations of eye creams and what is the surgical alternative?
While eye creams can help hydrate the skin, they cannot remove excess eyelid skin or fat. Blepharoplasty is the surgical treatment designed to remove excess eyelid skin or fat.
Does Dr. Carniol recommend regular facials?
Yes, regular facials are considered beneficial for a skin refresh.
What is the nature of hair transplantation?
Hair transplantation offers a permanent surgical solution for hair loss.
What is Dr. Carniol's approach to wound and scar care?
Initial local wound care involves washing, antiseptic hypochlorous acid, and ointment. After initial healing, Dr. Carniol utilizes sunscreen and silicone gel. For further scar revision, he considers treatments like CO2 laser or Neogen plasma regeneration.

From Dr. Paul Carniol's Instagram

@carniolplasticsurgery →

Recent photos posted by @carniolplasticsurgery, Dr. Paul Carniol's own Instagram account. Each image opens the original post on Instagram.

Images © Dr. Paul Carniol / @carniolplasticsurgery, shown here with a link to the original post. Procedure labels are inferred from the post's caption and hashtags. If you are the account owner and want an image removed, contact support [at] navmds.com.

Technologies & brands Dr. Paul Carniol mentions

Devices, implants, injectables and products named in Dr. Paul Carniol's own posts and videos. A mention is not an endorsement; ask the office what they currently offer.

LasersCO2 laser

Patient Experience

Dr. Paul Carniol Review Summary

4.96
Dr. Carniol has exceptionally high ratings across multiple platforms. He boasts a near-perfect average of 4.96 out of 5 stars, reflecting consistent praise from his patients.

Ratings from Other Platforms

healthgrades.com

4.9 out of 5

Based on 78 reviews

View on healthgrades.com

facebook.com

5 out of 5

Based on 4 reviews

View on facebook.com

health.usnews.com

5 out of 5

Based on 157 reviews

View on health.usnews.com

yelp.com

5 out of 5

Based on 1 reviews

View on yelp.com
Dr. Paul Carniol, MD - Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon in Summit, New Jersey

Carniol Plastic Surgery - Summit

33 Overlook Rd., Ste. 401, Summit, New Jersey

Book a Service Consultation

Consultation fee: $110

Each service is approximately 60 minutes.

+5 more

Industry Payments

Federal law (the Physician Payments Sunshine Act) requires drug and medical-device companies to report anything of value they give to a physician — consulting and speaking fees, research funding, travel, royalties, and even meals. Medicare publishes all of it in a public database called Open Payments. We show it here so you don't have to go looking for it.

Total received (2025)

$675

Payments

22

Compared to peers

Modest

Dr. Paul Carniol received $675 across 22 payments in 2025. That is higher than about 57% of the physicians here who received any industry payment. Most of it was categorised as food and beverage, and the largest single payer was REVANCE THERAPEUTICS, INC..

What this means for your care

  • A disclosed payment is a business relationship, not evidence of wrongdoing, and it says nothing on its own about the quality of your care.
  • Most payments are small. Across the physicians listed on NavMDs, the single most common category is food and beverage at industry-sponsored talks.
  • Larger consulting, speaking or royalty payments mean an ongoing financial relationship with a company whose products your doctor may use or recommend. That is worth knowing about, and it is reasonable to ask about.
  • A fair question to ask: “Do you have a financial relationship with the maker of the implant, filler or device you're recommending — and what alternatives did you consider?”

Source: CMS Open Payments, the federal database created by the Sunshine Act. View the full record on CMS Open Payments ↗

Patient Awards

Castle Connolly Top Doctor

Insurance Information

Please contact Dr. Paul Carniol's office directly for information about accepted insurance plans.

Help us improve this profile

Do you know which insurance plans Dr. Paul Carniol accepts? Share this information to help other patients.

Location & Contact Information

Carniol Plastic Surgery - Summit

33 Overlook Rd., Ste. 401

Summit, New Jersey

Office Information

Where does Dr. Paul Carniol practice?

Doctor's Office

Carniol Plastic Surgery - Summit (Primary)

33 Overlook Rd., Ste. 401, Summit, New Jersey

(10 reviews)

Hospital Affiliations

Atlantic Health System

Help improve our data. Confirm if Dr. Paul Carniol is affiliated with Atlantic Health System.

Education & Experience

Certifications & Licenses

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon
Double Board-certified Plastic Surgeon
Castle Connolly Top Doctor
Facs

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you make an appointment with Dr. Paul Carniol online?
The provided information doesn't confirm online booking, but suggests contacting the office directly for consultations. Patients are encouraged to book a consultation with Dr. Carniol to explore their treatment options.
Does Dr. Paul Carniol offer telehealth?
Telehealth availability isn't mentioned in the provided information.
What do patients have to say about Dr. Paul Carniol?
Patients rave about Dr. Carniol's skill and results, highlighting his expertise in scar removal, lipoma removal, facial rejuvenation, Botox, and laser resurfacing. Reviewers of all ages, including those seeking procedures for children and those in their 60s and 70s, praise his technique and the fantastic experience he provides.
What areas of care does Dr. Paul Carniol cater to?
Dr. Carniol specializes in facial plastic and reconstructive surgery, otolaryngology, and cosmetic surgery. His expertise includes facial rejuvenation procedures, laser skin resurfacing, scar removal, lipoma removal, and injectables like Botox and dermal fillers. Prioritizes patient comfort by utilizing local anesthesia for many in-office procedures, ensuring patients are completely at ease and pain-free without the need for deeper sedation. Offers flexibility with both in-office treatments and operating room procedures. His laser skin resurfacing expertise addresses deeper concerns such as fine lines, wrinkles, acne scars, and sun damage.